The Practical Guide to Being a Christian Stoic, Part 2: Calm Is Chosen

In the last post I told you about the Navy discharge papers we found after my grandfather died. They said he had suffered from a nervous disorder. Yet he was the calmest man I ever knew.

I keep coming back to that paper because it answers the question every anxious person carries around: can someone like me actually change? Or is calm just something certain people are born with?

My grandfather's life says calm can be chosen. The Stoics would agree. And the Christian faith takes that hope further than the Stoics ever could.

The jolt is not the choice

Epictetus taught that people are not disturbed by things, but by the judgments they make about things. A bad report from the doctor, a customer who won't pay, a business that fails: these are events. The panic comes from what we tell ourselves they mean.

That can sound like the Stoics expected us to feel nothing. They didn't. Seneca wrote about what later writers called first movements: the jolt in your chest, the racing pulse, the flush of fear that hits before you have time to think. Those reactions are involuntary. Even the wisest person feels them.

What matters is the next step. Do you agree with the jolt? Do you let it tell you the story of what happens next, or do you stop and examine it? For an anxious person, this is freeing. The first wave of fear is not a failure. The only question is what you do with it.

Where Christ goes further

Here is where the Christian Stoic parts ways with the pagan one. The Stoic sage aimed to stand above his emotions. Jesus did not. He wept at Lazarus' tomb. In Gethsemane, he was troubled to the point of sweating like drops of blood. Our Lord felt every first movement we feel, and more.

So the goal is not to stop feeling. The goal is to know what to do with what we feel. The Stoic examines the fear and sets aside what is not his to control. The Christian does the same, then takes one more step: he hands what is not his to Someone.

Saint Paul puts it plainly: do not be anxious about anything, but in everything, by prayer and petition, with thanksgiving, present your requests to God. And the peace of God, which passes all understanding, will guard your heart and mind. Saint Peter says it in fewer words: cast all your cares on Him, because He cares for you.

Epictetus could tell you to let go. He could not tell you who would catch it.

The practice

This is a practical guide, so here is what it looks like on an ordinary Tuesday. When the jolt hits, walk through three steps.

  1. Name it. Say to yourself, "This is a first movement." You are not your fear. You are the one noticing it.

  2. Sort it. Ask, "What part of this is mine to control?" Usually it is smaller than you think: your next action, your words, your attitude. Do that part.

  3. Hand over the rest. Take whatever is left and give it to God in prayer, as plainly as Paul says to. Then leave it there.

At the end of the day, add a short evening review. Seneca did this every night, and Christians have long practiced a similar examination of conscience. Ask three questions:

  • Where did fear try to run my day?

  • Where did I sort well, and where did I try to carry what was not mine?

  • What do I need to hand over before I sleep?

None of this works the first time. My grandfather did not become calm in a single afternoon on a bridge. He decided there, and then he practiced for the rest of his life.

What the paper didn't say

His calm didn't show up in big speeches. It showed up in ordinary days. He was up before my grandmother every morning, cooking breakfast, a cup of coffee never far from his hand. When something made him angry, he didn't explode. He got quiet. I can't remember him ever being angry with me, and I can't remember ever hearing him complain. That wasn't because life went easy on him. He had lost a business and buried a son. He had simply decided, a long time before, what he would let fear and frustration do to him.

The Navy recorded what my grandfather struggled with. It had no place on the form for what he became. That part was written over a lifetime, one choice at a time, and I got to read it by watching him.

If you carry anxiety, you are not disqualified. You are in good company. Start with the next jolt. Name it, sort it, and hand over the rest.

Common Protestant Objections to Catholic Doctrine by Kevin Mays

Kevin's book

Common Protestant Objections to Catholic Doctrine

A former Reformed pastor takes the hardest Protestant objections seriously and answers them from Scripture and Church history.

Get it on Amazon
Next
Next

The Practical Guide to Being a Christian Stoic, Part 1: The Day He Locked the Doors